Refusals and appeals
Procedural Fairness Letter (PFL) from IRCC: How to Respond
A procedural fairness letter, or PFL, means an IRCC officer has a concern serious enough to refuse your application and is giving you the opportunity to answer it first. The deadline is written in the letter and it is usually short. We read the letter with you, work out exactly what the officer suspects, and prepare a written response with the evidence to back it.

What a PFL is telling you
Officers send a PFL when they are leaning toward refusal and the law requires them to let you respond. The letter names the concern, sometimes in a single sentence. The common ones:
- Possible misrepresentation. The officer believes something in the application is false, or that something important was left out: a previous refusal, a family member, a job, a marriage.
- Doubts about documents. A reference letter, bank statement, degree or job offer the officer couldn't verify.
- A relationship that doesn't look genuine in a sponsorship file.
- Inadmissibility. A criminal record, a medical finding or a security concern. See inadmissibility.
The officer decides on your response plus the file, and if the case later goes to court, the judge generally reviews that same record.
Why misrepresentation is the concern to take most seriously
A misrepresentation finding under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act usually means the application is refused and you become inadmissible to Canada for five years. During that period you can't apply for permanent residence, and a new temporary application doesn't overcome the finding; a temporary resident permit or a challenge to the decision may be available. What else follows depends on where you are and what status you hold: someone in Canada can face a removal order, and a permanent resident's status itself can be put at risk. A finding can be made even when the mistake was not deliberate, for example when a consultant or a family member filled in the form and left out a past refusal. The courts recognize a narrow exception for honest and reasonable mistakes, and the response is where you show it applies.
How we prepare a PFL response
- 1 Decode the letter We identify the exact allegation and what the officer seems to have relied on, sometimes by requesting the officer's notes.
- 2 Rebuild the facts What happened, when, and who prepared which part of the application, with a date for each step.
- 3 Gather proof Original records, letters from employers or schools, affidavits from the people involved, and translations where needed.
- 4 Write the submission A clear answer to each concern, tied to the evidence and to the law the officer has to apply.
- 5 File on time If the deadline is truly too short, we ask the officer for more time in writing, before it passes.
What to do today
Don't reply on your own in a hurry, and don't ignore the letter. Note the deadline, gather the application you filed, and book a consultation. A short, accurate response with documents is far stronger than a long personal letter. If the decision has already gone against you, the next step may be the Federal Court: see judicial review of a refusal.
Writing for the officer and for the court
We write every PFL response knowing that, if the answer is still no, the same record is what a Federal Court judge will read. As a general rule, new evidence can't be added at the court stage, so the documents, affidavits and explanations all have to be in the response. If the officer's concern is well founded, we tell you, and we plan what it means for your next application.

Your lawyer
Ronen Kurzfeld
Licensed by the Law Society of Ontario, LSO #44363R. Office in Toronto; consultations in person, by video or by phone.
About RonenQuestions about procedural fairness letters
How long do I have to answer a PFL?

The deadline is in the letter. It is often a few weeks or less. Extensions are possible but not guaranteed, so ask early and in writing.
Can I just explain that it was an honest mistake?

You can, but explanations alone rarely carry it. The response needs documents and a clear account of how the mistake happened.
What happens if I don't respond?

The officer decides on the file as it stands, which is likely to mean a refusal, and possibly a misrepresentation finding.
Does a PFL mean my application will be refused?

No. It means the officer has a concern, and a well-documented response can answer it.
Note the deadline, then call us
Book a consultation or call 416-225-9800 today, and bring the letter and the application you filed. Refused after a PFL on an Express Entry file? See Express Entry and PR refusals.
